Vintage jewelry has emerged as a defining accessory for those seeking to express individuality and elevate personal style. Whether it’s a chunky gold costume necklace or a delicate Victorian cocktail ring, these pieces command attention and tell stories of eras past—making them standout additions to any wardrobe.
As gold prices reach record highs, interest in vintage fine jewelry is growing—not only for its aesthetic value but also for its potential as a long-term investment. Simultaneously, a new generation of collectors and fashion enthusiasts is embracing vintage costume jewelry, drawn to its affordability and uniqueness.
Unlike vintage handbags or clothing—which can occasionally lead to style overlap—vintage jewelry remains refreshingly one-of-a-kind. The chances of encountering someone wearing the same antique necklace or brooch are rare, which adds to its allure.
For those in New York City looking to explore the world of vintage and antique jewelry, several standout locations offer curated collections ranging from museum-quality pieces to budget-friendly treasures.
Pippin Vintage Jewelry
Situated between Union Square and Chelsea, Pippin is a veritable treasure trove of vintage adornments. The boutique features a wide selection, including Victorian mourning jewelry, 1950s brooches by brands like Weiss and Coro, antique coral pieces, heavy gold rings from the 1980s, and mid-century watches. The store’s eclectic, small-town atmosphere invites exploration and surprise at every turn.
Amarcord
Located in Brooklyn, Amarcord is known for its expertly curated selection of vintage designer costume jewelry. Shoppers will find iconic pieces from Chanel, Yves Saint Laurent, and Karl Lagerfeld, alongside bold, unsigned statement jewelry. Highlights include collar necklaces, oversized brooches, and rare runway pieces, complemented by more accessible items from classic labels like Monet.
Kentshire
Housed within the legendary Bergdorf Goodman, Kentshire offers high-end antique fine jewelry dating from the Victorian era to the 1980s. A family-run business since the 1940s, the shop boasts luxury items such as gold necklaces from Tiffany & Co. and Cartier, Art Deco diamond bracelets, and rare coral pieces from Van Cleef & Arpels. Shoppers will also find antique rings and a curated assortment of designer costume jewelry.
Chelsea Flea
Held every weekend on West 25th Street, Chelsea Flea features a rotating group of vendors offering a diverse array of vintage finds. From $5 costume pieces to rare Victorian lockets and Southwest turquoise, the market rewards those willing to dig and ask questions. It’s a haven for treasure hunters and casual browsers alike.
Icon Style
On the Upper West Side, Icon Style presents a mix of antique and costume jewelry with an emphasis on the unique. Shoppers can discover Georgian brooches, Victorian snake rings, sterling silver necklaces from the early 20th century, and whimsical animal-themed brooches. The shop offers an immersive browsing experience filled with unexpected delights.
Gray & Davis
Located on West 13th Street, Gray & Davis caters to antique jewelry collectors with pieces like moonstone festoon necklaces, diamond rivieras, and engraved lockets. The boutique is known for its Victorian snake chains and intricately designed bracelets, offering a blend of old-world craftsmanship and heirloom appeal.
City Opera Thrift Shop
Nestled in Chelsea, this boutique features a tightly curated selection of costume jewelry priced under $100. Standout items include bold statement necklaces, vintage brooches, and dramatic gold-tone chokers from the 1980s. Purchases support the New York City Opera, blending style with philanthropy.
Sheri’s Vintage Costume Jewelry and Bridal Jewelry Salon
Sheri’s offers a maximalist paradise of vintage costume pieces. With an extensive inventory of oversized gold-tone necklaces, clip-on earrings, and rings, the shop emphasizes bold, impactful jewelry that transforms any outfit. It’s a go-to for those seeking pieces with personality and flair.
The RealReal (SoHo Location)
Known for its high-end consignment, The RealReal’s SoHo boutique also houses a robust jewelry section. Offerings include unsigned vintage and secondhand fine jewelry, such as 1970s gold bracelets, 1940s gem-set tubogas necklaces, and vintage engagement rings. Shoppers can also find staples from Cartier and Van Cleef & Arpels, making it a key destination for luxury seekers.
Whether seeking a rare Victorian locket, a bold 1980s statement piece, or a timeless engagement ring, New York City’s vintage jewelry scene offers unparalleled variety and charm—ensuring that every piece is as unique as the person who wears it.
